Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Amazon can't evade taxes for money earned in France. If you operate in France, and your business earns revenue in France, you pay French taxes. You can't magically offshore it without paying taxes and then expect to still operate there.

What actually happens is that Amazon makes no profit, and thus does not get taxed on profits. But it still pays VAT, Property, B&O, etc.



It's actually quite easy to evade taxes on money earned in a particular country, as you are allowed to subtract inputs from your tax burden.

So the French subsidiary buys very expensive inputs from the Luxembourg subsidiary, meaning the French subsidiary doesn't show a profit, mon dieu how could that have happened, such a shame!

Fortunately, the Luxembourg subsidiary is very profitable, exclusively from "sales" to the French subsidiary.

Obviously all of this typically happens only on paper.


This is worth clarifying because all multi-nationals operate that way.

Say Starbucks-France makes 10 billion in profit in a year.

Then that year Starbucks-Luxembourg will send it an invoice saying "You owe us 10 billion for a license to use the name Starbucks".

That way SB-France, on paper, made no profit and pays no income tax.


Amazon customers pay VAT. Amazon collects it from the customer.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: