The logic makes sense if you assume that the NSA is only using the data to target terrorists. In that scenario, the danger isn't that they will reveal to innocent civilians that they have your data. The danger is the precedent. Want to know if you are on their target list? File a FOIA. If they grant it, you're okay. If they deny it, you're in their sights.
But since we already know that they are collecting this metadata on absolutely everyone, I don't see what good it does to refuse to send it to you, whether you are a suspected terrorist or not. ...I suppose you could be fretting about whether you had slipped up and called Cousin Guido on your regular cell instead of a throw-away prepaid phone.
But since we already know that they are collecting this metadata on absolutely everyone, I don't see what good it does to refuse to send it to you, whether you are a suspected terrorist or not. ...I suppose you could be fretting about whether you had slipped up and called Cousin Guido on your regular cell instead of a throw-away prepaid phone.