Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Statistics suggest

>facts

Statistical inference is not established fact. I'm not defending parent comment above, but to be clear, it's not actually established as a fact that "Maria" was black, right? "Maria" isn't even her real name.



Correction as stated below: "Statistics suggest that Maria was undoubtedly poor and, most likely, Black."


It very explicitly guesses that she is black, based solely on statistical inference.

From TFA: "Statistics suggest that Maria was undoubtedly poor and, most likely, Black."

To read this as established fact is analogous to asserting as established fact that if you roll a six-sided die, you will certainly get a number <= 4. Probable, but not fact.

A careful read also reveals that none of the woman's actual identifying information was revealed, including her name, for her own privacy:

"We’ll call her Maria, the most common female name in Brazil, because authorities have not disclosed her real name in order to protect her identity."

Follow-up edit: thank you for your correction, I appreciate the epistemic humility and good-faith dialogue.


The family exploiting the woman was, in fact, white, independent of her skin colour.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: