Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Everyone else can move literally anywhere else in the country

This sentiment makes me so angry. People -- very obviously -- need to live where the jobs are.

The fact that we want to say "oh, well if you don't want to live in the rent-seeking machine just go live in the desert" is the left-wing version of "pull yourself up by your bootstraps."

The fact is this. A housing crisis is a slow motion cascade. The landowners profit exactly because housing has been turned into a zero sum game. The more they profit, the more the political opposition will grow. Because the most desirable areas have been cordoned off, every single new resident will likely be on the losing side of the rent-seeking, and thus a pro-housing advocate. Thus, the political situation is a slow motion cascade, and the dam will break, every new building brings more pro-housing voters, every new building makes another new building more likely.

We could end this cycle by working together, but living in San Francisco, the side that has chosen to support rent-seeking cares only about themselves. You can see the political panic happening now. Scott Wiener will be our new rep. We will have hundreds of new units in the Marina. The west side has been upzoned. The only reason we're having the conversation is because the rent-seekers are starting to lose.

 help



> housing has been turned into a zero sum game

Not really. Land has always been zero-sum because there is a limited amount to compete for.

And location is status, even in high density developments (status is often seen as zero-sum).

Book review of Bird's The Land Trap that contains nice detail of unobvious monetary implications: https://progressandpoverty.substack.com/p/book-review-the-la...


>Not really. Land has always been zero-sum

What? Yes, but you misunderstand.

When you (intentionally) make expanding the housing supply illegal or practically impossible, then you've turned housing into a zero-sum game.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: