Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Unless I'm really stupid, this only works if you happened to buy in 1973.

You see the big downward trends in the stocks in 1998 and 2007?

Now pretend you invested in 1997 or 2006 instead of 1973. All of a sudden the graph would be transformed to show Gold as the clear winner. The guy's clearly an amateur, even as someone who has no interest in stocks whatsoever, never take advice from someone like this.

If you invest at the wrong time you lose money. The problem with graphs like this demonstrating the 'long-term' is that people conveniently pick a year that works for their point. The other common one is that people always pick just after the great depression to demonstrate stock market growth over time.



the same can be said of gold. if you pick gold anytime from 70-95 it loses out on stocks. Also, I don't see the big downward trend in 98, as we didn't peak until 2000 ;-)

The real takeaway is to not try and time the market. don't just buy all at once. if you continually invest over time you will have much less volatile returns, and continually investing over almost any period the stock market has higher returns than the other asset classes mentioned.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: