Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I wonder what assumptions are baked into our search for extraterrestrial life. Would we recognize a life-form that is gaseous? One that is planet-sized? One that communicates so slowly that it takes a thousand years to make a single sentence?


In Greg Egan's diaspora, they touch on things like this.

I can't remember specifically but at one point they encounter a planet where there is some process that is turning complete, and they realize an entire universe is simulated in the process with sentient beings that they can never communicate with.

I can't remember the details so I'm butchering it a little, but it's a great read.

Diaspora and Permutation City also touch on the topic of speeding up or slowing down conscious so that millenia pass in subjective seconds, or a subjective second passes in a millisecond, etc.


I believe you are referring to Wang's Carpets [1], which is part of Diaspora, but also as a short story.

[1] https://timeteam.github.io/fiction/2016/12/21/wangs-carpets....


Yes this is it, thank you. I didn't realize it was also a short story.


There's another interesting possibility: a rogue planet.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogue_planet

Under specific conditions, such a planet may even retain an atmosphere, have moderate surface temperatures (and thus, perhaps even liquid water), and life could exist on it if chemically-powered rather than using photosynthesis.

Such a planet would be an excellent vehicle to carry life from one star system to another. And another plus: out of a star system's influence sphere (while free-wandering through space), it could have very stable conditions over long periods of time. Which doesn't hurt in the formation or evolution of life.

True, there's a lot of (big) if's there. But the universe is biiiiiigggg so I wouldn't rule it out.


The assumptions are life looks like is.

Also, in regards to life using electrical signals to process information, gaseous clouds would have to generate signals with lower entropy than white noise from exploding stars.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: