Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

We have found many ancient civilizations with a technology on par with the Iron Age. They’re called Iron Age civilizations.


Sorry, I mean, long before the iron age.


If a civilization was discovered with Iron Age technology before what is the currently accepted beginning of the Iron Age, wouldn't that just mean the Iron Age started earlier than previously thought?


I would argue that it needs to be more or less continuous, if we lost the technology it's a different age imo. Or at least, you can't go back globally multiple ages :) if multiple civilizations discover iron working from an otherwise similar stage of technology but aren't entirely continuous then I think it's reasonable to combine them, but if they all go back to the stone age and start from scratch I'd argue it doesn't make sense to combine them.


> I would argue that it needs to be more or less continuous, if we lost the technology it's a different age imo.

You're looking at history through modern eyes. Back in the past there was no collective `we`, we were much more separated as a species than we are now.

The idea that there is a global 'us' is a very, very new idea.


Also whole Iron Age as term is rather weird and location specific. In Europes there are places where it is considered to ended in 1200-1300.. Yes, during Middle Ages...


No need to apologize, HN people get off on being snarky


It would also mean that technology - and human condition - remained stagnant for half million years. If true it has [no good] implications for [the answer to] the so called Fermi Paradox.

Edited for clarity




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: