Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Script integration is not dropped. You can easily run a script from a unit file.


Yea, they're dropping the native generator for /etc/init.d, I believe. Scripts placed here implicitly became systemd services.

Nothing of huge value is lost. Distributions play an important part, we shouldn't forget. They can maintain something like this for users, if so inclined.

This mostly hurts third party/ancient/naive packages that you probably, eventually, won't want to install on your distribution for other reasons.

This won't affect any packages natively provided by your distribution of choice. Think those random RPMs/DEBs you get from an external vendor -- UPS, keyboard, whatever.

They've had over a decade to see the writing on the wall, adding ~12 lines to their entire codebase/packaging spec. Probably a net-reduction given the NIH-syndrome of these scripts.

Instead, I've seen them make this directory, put their scripts inside, and just expect things to work out. It did, arguably by chance. The compatibility was deliberate, but support isn't forever.


That’s wild! I too have seen horror I wish I could forget.

For those still worried, the pain is limited to about 15 minutes of writing a unit file, testing it, and waiting for ci or builds to finish!

I expect to have to do this for older or more esoteric stuff, but I also enjoy writing unit files.


> I expect to have to do this for older or more esoteric stuff, but I also enjoy writing unit files

You can’t even do that as those are not deterministic.


I can’t do what? Write unit files for older applications? Because unit files? the applications? are not deterministic?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: