Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

These chords progress in units of 2. So you start with your triad (1st, 3rd, 5th). For the 7th chord you add the 7th, naturally enough. The next chord is then a 9th chord, so you add a 9th interval, but it wraps around modulo 8, so it's really a 2nd interval (since intervals are 1-indexed). Next it's an 11th chord, but the interval is really a 4th, and so on. The idea is to think of them spread out though, as successive thirds.


This has always bothered me.

In what's typically called a 13th chord, the 11th is almost always omitted because it either clashes, or it changes the chord into something completely different. Stacking 3rds doesn't actually explain how jazz chords work. And it tends to produce corny voicings.

To make an analogy with computers, it feels like the classical notation is an abstraction layer which has been extended beyond its usefulness.


that was sort of the realization I had that led to the post; it isn't about stacking 3rds and that's what misled me for all those years.


but the idea of my post is to point out why it isn't just the module 8 wrapped version. C13 means C + 6th + 7th not just C + 13th = C + 6th




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: