Agreed. Home maintenance, property tax, mortgage interest, is a cost of owning regardless of whether you are renting or living in it. So that needs to always be part of your calculation, and I would hope most landlords are considering that.
I was just hypothesizing that the "Bad Tenant tax" is potentially overblown. Sure it can be an absolute nightmare if you're unlucky (or bad at screening), but on average I suspect it's pretty minor. I honestly don't have anything but anecdotal data to back that up though. I just suspect, like a lot of things where exceptional horror stories are propagated, we could be over-weighting the negatives.
The problem with small landlords is they can't average bad tenants over a large number of units. They have one or two units, and even one just sitting empty for a few months destroys years of cash flow.
Let alone actually getting a bad tenant. It may be a low chance, but if it comes up, you can be hosed out of the entire value of the house (usually you can still sell the land, but in the absolute worst cases where the property was turned into a meth factory, you may be out more than the entire value).
I was just hypothesizing that the "Bad Tenant tax" is potentially overblown. Sure it can be an absolute nightmare if you're unlucky (or bad at screening), but on average I suspect it's pretty minor. I honestly don't have anything but anecdotal data to back that up though. I just suspect, like a lot of things where exceptional horror stories are propagated, we could be over-weighting the negatives.