Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Scrolls is just an English word. You shouldn't be able to trademark it in the first place.


That's exactly how trademarks don't work. Windows. Apple. McDonalds (a proper name!). Name combinations: Pizza Hut, Quaker State, Bank of America.


Not to mention Bethesda


Yes I know how it works. I was commenting that I find the current system of being able to trademark English words like "orange" a pretty silly system.


You can't. Trademarks have domains in which they are functional. Microsoft owns "Windows", an English word, but only in the computer domain (whichever one that is). They do not own the word Windows. The system already does not let you simply trademark English words.


You really don't see a problem with someone other than Microsoft selling an operating system and calling it Windows?

What about a company that does mail delivery calling itself the "United States Postal Service" ?

An airline called "Virgin"?


It should be called 'microsoft windows'. That way we can have 'Apple windows', 'digital research windows' and so on. Window managers are a class and you should not be able to monopolize a class name without some sort of addition.


>Window managers are a class and you should not be able to monopolize a class name without some sort of addition.

The Windows trademark is for the entire operating system product. It's not just for the window manager.

Keep in mind that trademarks are incredibly specific. Infringement only occurs if it's a similar product. For example, there is a recreational vehicle company named Starcraft that has been in business since the early 1900's. Blizzard made the real time strategy game called Starcraft. Both usages of the word "Starcraft" are registered trademarks, and do not infringe on each other.


"Hello, I have a problem with Nokia Photoshop not loading on my Fujitsu-Siemens Macbook Pro after installing the latest upgrade of 'Google Snow Leopard Windows'".


"Google" is an English word, so you'll have to be a bit more specific.


"Well i tried Adobegoogling it, Microsoftgoogling, Googlegoogling and Quorastackoverflowing it, but no clear solution was found. I am gonna consider buying the Virgin Atlantic Photoshop CS4 instead from the Walmart App Store"


Technically, "Google" isn't an English word - it's a misspelling of the English word "googol."



The point is it was not a verb before Google the company


Trademark law is not patent law, it tends to be stricter, more restricted and much harder to abuse (although it can be abused, see Tim Langdell).


Apple.


It is trademarked within context, it is violated in its own context (video games).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: