Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

All of them? Banks was a socialist crafting a post-scarcity society.

https://www.tor.com/2017/11/24/the-revolutionary-optimism-of...

> On Earth one of the things that a large proportion of the locals is most proud of is this wonderful economic system which, with a sureness and certainty so comprehensive one could almost imagine the process bears some relation to their limited and limiting notions of either thermodynamics or God, all food, comfort, energy, shelter, space, fuel and sustenance gravitates naturally and easily away from those who need it most and towards those who need it least. Indeed, those on the receiving end of such largesse are often harmed unto death by its arrival, though the effects may take years and generations to manifest themselves.

“The State of the Art”



I did read them. And I don't remember any instance where Bezoses or Musks were actively sought out and disempowered.

On the contrary, they can develop stuff without having to ensure employees are happy and fed. That burden is taken care of by the AI. Plus, if their ideas are any good, AI will help further by offloading most of the corporate management. How can Musk and Bezos not like that?


Surface Detail's plot revolves around the take-down of the richest capitalist on a planet by the Culture.


Surface Detail's plot revolves around destroying a simulated version of hell. That it was hosted on that person's servers is just a detail.


Musk and Bezos routinely rape and kill people like Veppers does?


That's arguing in bad faith. Electronic Hells and Culture warships don't exist, either, but Banks can still be making social commentary via his work.

His socialism with a touch of anarchism was hardly a secret.


How is that in bad faith? I grew up in eastern europe and we got loads of such absurd "social commentary" that painted all bourgeoisie as bloodthirsty enslaving monsters. It actually had the opposite effect, contributed to uncritical adoration of the West.

So if we are going to have useful social commentary, let's perhaps focus on the actual and well-known psychopatic streaks of the CEOs and how they fit into their environment, not make comics villains out of them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: