Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Fulton Sheen has spilled a significant amount of ink against psychiatry, and against many forms of psychology, because they all reject the existence of the soul. And if the soul does exist, but we make all sorts of assumptions based on the idea that it doesn't, then all our conclusions will be tainted if not completely wrong. He talked quite a bit on depression, psychosis, neurosis, anxiety, and other mental conditions.

Incidentally, the stereotype that religion is only for the ignorant and that talking about it always devolves into an emotional and irrational argument, is only true for certain emasculated forms of Christianity, but not Catholicism, where Fulton Sheen proved that (high) intelligence is in no way contrary to religious belief, but actually religious concepts are better explained by those with higher intelligence.

Anecdotally, one of the biggest reasons I bring up religion so much, especially in threads like this, is because Catholicism was the only form of psychology that actually helped me overcome my many great mental disorders, and I am confident that it will be able to help others through their lesser and fewer forms than I had. But because of the extreme prejudice that intellectual people have against religion in general and Catholicism specifically, there has been almost no public progress in this field.

"Catholic counselors" have generally in my opinion been non-Catholic in their foundational principles and have in no way been able to help me, for example. And priests, although they should especially be educated about psychology from a Catholic foundation, especially in these days where it's more prevalent than ever (Fulton Sheen expands quit a bit on the reasoning), they have not seemed to recognize the serious need for this yet and have not caught up.

So almost all of my improvements have been from independent research on and application of these things. I really wish that the intelligentsia in general and here especially would catch up, especially when I see so many people struggling in many of the same ways I did and have overcome in the past few years. That's why I try so hard on here to convince them it's actually for them. If they only read Thomas Aquinas and Fulton Sheen they might see that it's actually more of an intellectual position than agnosticism or atheism are.

But sometimes it takes a person hitting rock bottom to realize that all their enlightened philosophy is useless to help them live a truly happy and fulfilling life. Sometimes only when we have the most pressure do we consider alternatives that may be a bit unpalatable to our preferences.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: