Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> people do not need to profit from housing to build it

People do need to profit from something to do it in a capitalist society.



As opposed to what? Where in the world -- at any point in human history -- have people spontaneously made houses without any benefit to themselves?


Housing is not a market that should be governed by capitalism. I honestly don't care if the ultra-rich trade 30 million dollar homes and speculate on their value, but the fact that homelessness is even a problem in the first world is a travesty.

Our children will look back upon a time when there were 6 (SIX!) empty homes for every homeless person in the United States and weep. Obviously those homes aren't all where the homeless people are, but that's another problem itself: Why on earth are developers building homes in the middle of nowhere, why are they building luxury condos, and who the hell is buying them?


Homelessness is a problem of addiction and mental illness. Cheap highly regulated housing in the middle of expensive cities don't fix that.

Social workers and detox programs help, but there is no easy fix (other than "finance their life") for people who can't kick a drug habit, or are mentally incapable of holding down a job.


> Homelessness is a problem of addiction and mental illness.

Have you never spent time with homeless people? You are delusional.


I spend time with them every day. Hello from Seattle!


As I understand it, homelessness has more complex causes than simply not having access to affordable housing.


Sure, but the majority of it comes down to "money": https://i.imgur.com/aUvpH0S.png

The fact that we can't solve homelessness "just" by giving everyone easy access to affordable housing isn't an argument against affordable housing. It's an argument for better mental health services and a wider safety net.


The count in that graph also includes people living in temporary, public shelters. In my opinion, that makes it slightly less useful when attempting to determine the cause of people on the streets, which is what most people refer to as homelessness. It does seem silly to me to include those living in currently available public housing as 'homeless'. It's perfectly possible that most of those who lost jobs are currently housed in existing public options, and the majority of those on the streets are there due to addiction. Unfortunately, I couldn't find a breakdown of self-reported reasons for homelessness once those already sheltered were removed.

Source: http://allhomekc.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/2019-Report_..., Methodology Section, point 3, saying they include those living in shelters.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: