Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | hardlianotion's commentslogin

Most western democracies have exactly the same fault, maybe having unscrupulous, shameless legislators are the end state of the current models of democracy being practiced.

Which manifesto commitments have been blocked in this parliament?

> Which manifesto commitments have been blocked in this parliament?

To be clear, I didn't say they "blocked," I said:

> though the Lords recently have been playing silly buggers around the Employment Rights Act

This was a manifesto commitment which, while it eventually went through, it was touch and go for a little bit. Reporting at the time:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f412kJChC6g


Okay, though to be fair to me, you said just after

> and ignoring the Salisbury Convention (which is that they shouldn’t block manifesto commitments)

which is what attracted my question.

Thanks for the link. I haven’t watched it, but I will observe that a lot of the modern legislation that comes out of the commons should properly attract the attention of the Lords, as it doesn’t get nearly enough attention from the commons.


I totally agree, the upper chamber can and should make amendments to legislation. In this case, they made a generally good amendment to the Employment Rights Bill (allowing "at-will" dismissal up to the first 6 months rather than the initially proposed total ban).

However after that amendment was accepted, Conservative Peers (who hold a majority) initially voted against the bill again: https://bectu.org.uk/news/prospect-slams-house-of-lords-for-...

It was eventually passed a week later when the Lords accepted the Commons amendments but that second block on 11th December shouldn't have happened.


That is the only disappointing aspect of the site. It's genius.

RIP Dan

And is a decidedly superior breakfast.

The word "trillionaire" does not appear in the discussion. Not good form to imply quotes where there are none.


UK is European. Membership of EU is unnecessary for that criterion to be met.


Are all of these dark patterns seen in the wild? OR are some of these merely a dreadful warning of what may happen?


I think some examples are in order - where has the UK, having recently left the EU, changed its laws so that it was completely out of step with consumer protection? Or is this one thing that made it necessary for them to leave the union, perhaps?


He was arrested for sex trafficking minors and convicted procuring a child for prostitution.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: